Electric Griddles Compared (2026): Flat-Top or Reversible Plates?
By The Gear Audit Team · Original specification research September 9, 2026.
The Short Answer
Choose the surface before comparing wattage. We recommend Blackstone 8001 for a hooded flat top with two controlled zones, Presto 07061 when a full-width flat griddle must fit a crowded cabinet, and Hamilton Beach 38546MN when switching between smooth and ridged plates is the main reason to buy. Published watts do not establish even heating or better browning.
Blackstone 8001
Our pick when two foods need separate settings across one flat cooking style.
Presto 07061
Our pick when tool-free removable handles and an 18-inch-cabinet claim solve the ownership problem.
Hamilton Beach 38546MN
Our pick when ridged and smooth surfaces may be used in the same meal.
Compare the surface before the wattage
| Exact model | Surface and controls | Published size and power | Ownership detail |
|---|---|---|---|
| Blackstone 22-inch E-Series, 8001 | Ceramic-coated flat top; two controlled zones; LCD display | 17.25 W x 21.75 D x 9 H in; 1,600 W | Rotate-and-remove hood; rear grease management |
| Presto 22-inch griddle, 07061 | Textured ceramic flat surface; single automatic heat control | 120 V AC; 1,500 W | Tool-free removable handles; slide-out drip tray |
| Hamilton Beach 3-in-1, 38546MN | Two reversible plates; independent controls up to 425°F | 20.11 W x 11.02 D x 3.74 H in; 1,400 W | 180 sq in stated area; dishwasher-safe plates |
Pick the layout that matches breakfast or dinner
Blackstone 8001: a two-zone hooded flat top
Best for: A buyer who wants two separately controlled temperatures on a continuous flat cooking style and values a removable hood and rear grease system.
Pros
- Two heat zones support a split meal. Separate settings can keep eggs and another food on different heat plans without changing appliances.
- The hood and rear grease system shape the workflow. The rotate-and-remove hood covers the surface, while rear collection directs grease away from the front edge.
- The LCD gives a visible control reference. Buyers who prefer a digital setting display get one instead of relying only on an unmarked heat range.
Cons and trade-offs
- The surface is flat rather than reversible. Choose Hamilton Beach if ridged grilling is part of the meal instead of expecting the Blackstone surface to provide both textures.
- It needs meaningful counter depth. Blackstone lists a 21.75-inch depth, so measure the operating space and decide whether it will stay out before buying.
Choose something else if: Compact cabinet storage or grill ridges matter more than the hooded flat-top layout. Presto addresses storage with removable handles; Hamilton Beach provides smooth and ridged plates.
Our recommendation
We recommend Blackstone 8001 when the foods you cook together benefit from two settings on a flat top and you have a stable place for its published depth. The 1,600 W rating does not prove more even browning than the other models.
Price listing: Blackstone 8001 22-inch electric griddle.
Presto 07061: a full flat griddle that stores with handles removed
Best for: Pancakes, eggs and other flat-griddle meals in a kitchen where the appliance must fit a standard-depth cabinet after cooking.
Pros
- The handles remove without tools. Presto says the base then fits most standard 18-inch kitchen cabinets, giving storage-constrained buyers a concrete reason to shortlist it.
- One automatic heat control keeps the routine simple. The Control Master unit is described as maintaining the chosen temperature without managing two separate zones.
- The base has a practical cleanup route. A slide-out drip tray catches runoff, and the griddle is fully immersible after the heat control is removed.
Cons and trade-offs
- One control means one heat plan. Choose Blackstone or Hamilton Beach when two foods need independently adjusted settings at the same time.
- The cooking surface is flat only. Buyers who regularly want grill marks or ridged drainage should start with Hamilton Beach instead.
- Immersion requires removing the powered control. The cleanup advantage applies to the griddle base, not the complete connected appliance.
Choose something else if: Separate zones, a hood or reversible grill plates are more valuable than cabinet fit. Presto’s strongest buying case is storage plus a straightforward single-temperature flat surface.
Our recommendation
We recommend Presto 07061 when a large flat breakfast surface must disappear into a cabinet afterward. Measure the cabinet with space for the detached handles and control, and follow the heat-control removal instruction before immersion.
Price listing: Presto 07061 22-inch electric griddle.
Hamilton Beach 38546MN: smooth and ridged plates in one appliance
Best for: Meals that pair a smooth surface for eggs, pancakes or buns with a ridged surface for another food, sometimes at a different temperature.
Pros
- Three plate layouts change the job. Both plates can be smooth, both ridged, or one of each, so the appliance can act as a full griddle, full grill or split surface.
- Each zone has its own control. Hamilton Beach lists independent settings up to 425°F and permits using one side for a smaller meal.
- The removable plates simplify cleanup. The PFAS-free ceramic-coated plates are dishwasher-safe, and the drip tray is listed as top-rack dishwasher-safe.
Cons and trade-offs
- A mixed layout halves the continuous cooking texture. Using one ridged plate and one smooth plate is flexible, but a buyer needing one uninterrupted flat surface may prefer Presto or Blackstone.
- Changing the cooking style means handling the plates. The reversible pieces must be flipped and snapped back into place, so choose the layout before preheating rather than treating it as an instant mid-meal switch.
- The drip tray has a narrower dishwasher instruction. The plates are dishwasher-safe, while Hamilton Beach specifies the top rack for the tray.
Choose something else if: A hooded continuous flat top is central to the routine, or removable handles are needed for cabinet storage. Hamilton Beach earns its place through plate flexibility rather than those ownership features.
Our recommendation
We recommend Hamilton Beach 38546MN when the same appliance will genuinely be used as both grill and griddle. Set the two plate orientations before cooking, use one zone for smaller meals when useful, and do not treat the 1,400 W figure as an even-heating result.
Price listing: Hamilton Beach 38546MN.
Make a practical buying check
List the foods you regularly cook together. Decide whether one uninterrupted flat surface or mixed plate textures are more useful, then decide whether those foods need one setting or two. A second zone adds value only when the meal actually uses it.
Measure the operating location and the cabinet used for storage, including handles, control units, hood clearance and room for cleaning parts. Rated watts do not show surface uniformity, sticking or browning, and coating labels do not establish long-term durability.
Frequently asked questions
Which model combines a grill and a griddle?
Hamilton Beach 38546MN has two reversible plates. You can arrange both smooth, both ridged, or one of each. Blackstone 8001 and Presto 07061 use flat cooking surfaces.
Which is easier to fit in a cupboard?
Presto specifically documents removable handles and says its base fits most standard 18-inch cabinets after removal. Measure the cabinet and allow space for the detached handles and heat control.
Which models have two temperature zones?
Blackstone 8001 and Hamilton Beach 38546MN list two controlled zones. Presto 07061 uses one Control Master heat control, which better fits a single-temperature routine.
Does higher wattage prove more even cooking?
No. Rated power does not measure surface uniformity or browning. We have not temperature-mapped these griddles.
Can all parts go in water or the dishwasher?
No. Presto permits immersion only with the heat control detached. Hamilton Beach specifies dishwasher-safe plates and a top-rack-safe drip tray. Follow the exact-model cleaning instructions for each component.
Research method, primary sources and limitations
Amazon price check: Displayed prices come from Amazon’s product API for the named US listing, with a check time and a validity window under one hour. No numerical Amazon rating is shown because the current API responses did not supply usable review data. Pricing checks do not change the specification-research date.
Buying-advice update: September 13, 2026. Original specification research: September 9, 2026. We reviewed exact manufacturer pages for Blackstone 8001, Presto 07061 and Hamilton Beach 38546MN. Features and dimensions are manufacturer statements; recommendations are editorial judgments about surface layout, controls, cleaning and storage. We did not measure preheating, heat uniformity, browning or coating durability.
Price cards show a direct product link when a qualifying current Amazon offer is available. Other buttons are labelled as model searches. Confirm the exact model, voltage, accessories, condition and seller. Browse our Kitchen comparisons and research methodology.
Primary sources: Blackstone 8001 product page; Presto 07061 specifications; Hamilton Beach 38546MN specifications.
CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED “AS IS” AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.
Affiliate disclosure
As an Amazon Associate, The Gear Audit earns from qualifying purchases. We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Read our full affiliate disclosure.