Peloton Bike+ vs NordicTrack S22i in 2026: Which Should You Buy?
Quick answer
Choose the current Peloton Cross Training Bike+ for studio-led classes and off-bike routines when you will use its paid All-Access content. Consider an S22i only as an inspected, supported used unit if motorized incline and iFIT routes are the priority. For a new NordicTrack terrain bike, compare the X24. The machines differ more in training style, membership and buying risk than in screen size.
Side-by-side comparison
| Decision | Current Peloton Bike+ | NordicTrack S22i |
|---|---|---|
| Shopping status | Current Cross Training Bike+ listing | Legacy model; confirm condition, serial number and support before used purchase |
| Training focus | Studio classes, auto-resistance and off-bike classes | iFIT destination rides and motorized incline/decline |
| Display | 23.8-inch swiveling HD touchscreen | 22-inch HD touchscreen on maker legacy FAQ |
| Footprint | 54 × 22 inches body, plus training clearance | 55 × 29.1 inches on maker legacy FAQ |
| Membership | All-Access for full device content; Just Ride without membership | Confirm current iFIT compatibility and features for the exact used unit |
Our recommendation
For a new purchase centered on live and on-demand studio classes, buy the current Peloton Cross Training Bike+ if its All-Access membership fits your long-term budget. The S22i is a used-machine decision in 2026: its motorized incline and decline remain distinctive, but age, console generation, parts and iFIT compatibility matter more than an old spec sheet. If you want NordicTrack terrain training with a current retail model and support, compare the X24 Bike before committing to a used S22i. Neither company’s own workout or reliability claims establish a tested winner.
Peloton Cross Training Bike+: best for studio-led training
Best for: Households that expect to use Peloton classes and off-bike strength or yoga regularly.
Pros
- Swiveling screen supports floor workouts
- Auto-resistance follows supported instructor cues
- Current US product listing and delivery path
Cons and trade-offs
- Full content and applicable features depend on paid All-Access
- Delta-compatible shoes add a fit and accessory decision
- 144-pound bike and screen need planned delivery and workout clearance
Our recommendation
The current Bike+ page lists a 23.8-inch swiveling screen, automatic resistance that follows instructor cues, Sonos-tuned sound, a fan and a movement-tracking camera. Its Delta-compatible pedals require appropriate cycling shoes. The All-Access subscription unlocks full content; Peloton says Just Ride remains available without it. A bike bought for the class library should be evaluated with several years of membership cost, not only hardware cost.
Choose another if: You prefer outdoor-route simulation or want an open training display without a continuing content fee.
NordicTrack S22i: consider only as a verified used purchase
Best for: A buyer who specifically values motorized hill simulation, can inspect the unit locally and accepts used-machine support uncertainty.
Pros
- Motorized grade changes add a second terrain variable
- 22-inch screen and route-oriented iFIT experience
- Potential used-market value if condition and support are confirmed
Cons and trade-offs
- Legacy stock makes console generation and condition decisive
- Motorized incline adds a component to inspect and service
- 193.6-pound maker-listed machine complicates moving
Our recommendation
NordicTrack’s S22i FAQ lists a 22-inch touchscreen and 55 × 29.1-inch floor dimensions. Its terrain-style rides and motorized incline/decline distinguish it from Peloton’s resistance-focused Bike+. The maker FAQ dates from an earlier generation; do not treat its old introductory membership or warranty terms as current promises. Ask for model and serial number, test the console, incline motor, pedals and controls, then confirm iFIT and parts support for that exact version. A deep used discount may be attractive, but potential repair and pickup costs can erase it.
Choose another if: You need a new-machine warranty or cannot test the exact used bike before purchase.
How to decide
For a wider set of training styles, compare our exercise-bike guide. If seated cycling is not the right movement or floor-space use, our rowing-machine guide covers a different cardio setup.
Choose the training habit first
Peloton emphasizes studio classes, instructor cues and an ecosystem of off-bike sessions. The S22i emphasizes simulated routes and physical grade changes. A scenic interface is useful only if you enjoy riding it often. Try a class or demonstration before choosing based on screen size.
Budget for the software relationship
The feature-rich experience on both platforms is tied to a continuing membership. Peloton explicitly offers limited Just Ride without membership; its full content needs All-Access. On an S22i, confirm what the specific console and iFIT software still support. Membership promotions and pricing change, so compare current checkout terms rather than old article figures.
Measure access and workout clearance
Measure doorways, stairs, floor location and ceiling height before delivery. The Bike+ body measures 54 × 22 inches and Peloton recommends clearance around it. The S22i’s older FAQ lists a wider 29.1-inch body and a 193.6-pound weight. A floor mat and stable, level surface matter more than a compact footprint claim if the bike rocks during riding.
Inspect a used S22i like a machine
Request the model number and serial number, original proof of purchase if available, and a live test of start-up, resistance, grade movement, touchscreen, Wi-Fi and fan. Listen for abnormal noises and look for damaged cables or pedal threads. Confirm parts and subscription support directly with NordicTrack for that exact model before payment. If a seller cannot demonstrate it, a current model is a safer purchase path.
Consider the current NordicTrack alternative
The X24 Bike is NordicTrack’s current terrain-focused machine, with a 24-inch pivoting screen and a published -10% to 20% incline range. It is not the S22i and should not be used to infer the legacy bike’s features. Compare it when the goal is a new bike with current service, then assess iFIT Pro requirements and the total cost.
Frequently asked questions
Is the S22i still a current new NordicTrack model?
NordicTrack’s current US bike range highlights newer models including X24. Treat an S22i listing as generation-specific and verify whether it is old stock, refurbished or used.
Can Bike+ work without a membership?
Peloton says Just Ride works without a membership, while the full class library and applicable features require All-Access.
Does Peloton Bike+ incline like S22i?
No. Bike+ changes pedal resistance; the S22i physically changes grade. The current NordicTrack X24 also has motorized incline and decline.
Which bike is more reliable?
We have no comparable original reliability or failure-rate records. Condition and service support are especially important for a used S22i.
What shoes are required?
Peloton Bike+ uses Delta-compatible cleats. Check the exact S22i pedal configuration and fit before purchase rather than assuming one shoe standard.
Is a bigger screen enough reason to choose Bike+?
No. The content, subscription, physical fit, controls and service path will affect use more than 1.8 inches of display diagonal.
Research method and primary sources
We compared current maker information for Bike+ with NordicTrack’s archived S22i documentation and current X24 listing. We have no original ride, durability or reliability tests. The S22i FAQ is historical, so reconfirm support and terms for the exact unit.
Primary sources: Current Peloton Bike+ US product page; Peloton Just Ride and membership support; NordicTrack S22i legacy FAQ; Current NordicTrack X24 US page. Our methodology.
Affiliate disclosure
As an Amazon Associate, The Gear Audit earns from qualifying purchases. We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Full affiliate disclosure.