Best Exercise Bikes 2026: Five Training Styles Compared
Quick answer
For studio workouts, the current Peloton Cross Training Bike+ makes sense if its All-Access classes justify the continuing cost. The Schwinn IC4 is more flexible for tablet-based workouts, while NordicTrack X24 adds physical hill simulation. Echelon EX-5s-22 is another built-in-screen option; Sunny Active 100 is a simpler magnetic bike. Fit and training habit matter more than a screen-size contest.
Compare the five training approaches
| Bike | Training approach | Main constraint |
|---|---|---|
| Peloton Cross Training Bike+ | Immersive studio classes | Full content requires paid All-Access membership |
| Schwinn IC4 | Flexible tablet-based training | No integrated class display; supply your own phone or tablet |
| NordicTrack X24 Bike | Motorized terrain riding | Full connected content and auto-adjust features need iFIT Pro and Wi-Fi |
| Echelon Connect EX-5s-22 | Screen-led class alternative | Full Echelon class experience depends on Premier membership |
| Sunny Health & Fitness Active 100 SF-B124066 | Basic connected magnetic bike | Handlebars have no adjustment listed |
Our recommendation
Choose Peloton Bike+ only if you want its classes often enough to pay for All-Access. Otherwise, Schwinn IC4 gives you a service-neutral starting point with usable onboard metrics. NordicTrack X24 earns its extra complexity if physical grade changes and iFIT routes motivate you. Echelon is a screen-led alternative with its own membership; Sunny Active 100 keeps the hardware simple but has a fixed handlebar. No bike here is proven to produce better health outcomes, and a correct, comfortable fit is more important than advertised calorie or class counts.
Peloton Cross Training Bike+: Immersive studio classes
Best for: A rider who plans to use Peloton classes and off-bike sessions most weeks.
Pros
- 23.8-inch swivel screen for cycling and floor work
- Auto-resistance on supported instructor rides
- Current US Bike+ includes fan and phone tray
Cons and trade-offs
- Full content requires paid All-Access membership
- Delta-compatible cycling shoes are needed
- 144-pound unit needs delivery and floor-space planning
Our recommendation
The current Bike+ is more than a bike with a screen: the rotating display makes strength and yoga sessions viable in the same spot, and auto-resistance can follow supported instructor cues. Peloton’s current page also lists a fan and movement camera, so do not confuse it with earlier Bike+ generations. Just Ride works without a subscription, but the reason to buy this hardware is the paid class system. Add several years of All-Access costs to your decision and check shoe fit before ordering.
Choose another if: You want open app choice or do not want an ongoing content membership.
Schwinn IC4: Flexible tablet-based training
Best for: A rider who wants magnetic resistance and a tablet holder without being tied to one built-in class screen.
Pros
- 100 indexed magnetic resistance levels
- Dual-sided SPD and toe-cage pedals
- Basic LCD works apart from a class subscription
Cons and trade-offs
- No integrated class display; supply your own phone or tablet
- App integrations may need separate subscriptions
- Resistance does not automatically follow app workouts
Our recommendation
IC4 has a backlit metric console and a tablet shelf, so you can ride with local metrics or connect to supported services. Schwinn lists 100 resistance settings and dual-sided pedals, useful for households with both cycling shoes and trainers. App compatibility does not mean all app functions or subscriptions are included; verify your chosen platform’s current pairing behavior. The maker lists a 54.6 × 30.7-inch footprint and 113.6-pound assembled weight, so it still needs dedicated space.
Choose another if: You want a built-in large display or instructor-controlled resistance.
NordicTrack X24 Bike: Motorized terrain riding
Best for: A rider who wants physical incline and decline alongside route-oriented iFIT sessions.
Pros
- Published -10% to 20% motorized grade range
- 24-inch pivoting HD screen
- 24 resistance levels and integrated handle controls
Cons and trade-offs
- Full connected content and auto-adjust features need iFIT Pro and Wi-Fi
- Incline mechanism adds maintenance complexity
- Larger screen and motorized frame demand space and a careful delivery plan
Our recommendation
X24 is the current NordicTrack alternative to the older S22i, not a renamed S22i. Its published -10% decline to 20% incline creates a physical grade change while iFIT can change resistance and terrain during supported sessions. That extra mechanical dimension appeals to route training, but it also adds components to maintain. NordicTrack’s calorie-burn comparisons are manufacturer claims, not an outcome we verified. Budget for iFIT Pro if automated scenic training is the attraction.
Choose another if: You want a simple bike that does not depend on a connected training ecosystem.
Search Amazon US for NordicTrack X24 Bike (confirm exact model and generation).
Echelon Connect EX-5s-22: Screen-led class alternative
Best for: A household wanting a 22-inch flipping screen and dual-sided pedals for Echelon classes.
Pros
- 22-inch screen flips for off-bike sessions
- 32 magnetic resistance levels
- SPD-compatible clips plus toe cages
Cons and trade-offs
- Full Echelon class experience depends on Premier membership
- 58-inch length needs more room than compact bikes
- Built-in screen ties training to Echelon software
Our recommendation
The EX-5s-22 offers a big screen, class library and a seat and handlebar that adjust in two directions. It competes on an immersive format, not by duplicating Peloton’s current Bike+ features. The current Echelon listing is a Black or Mossy Oak variant and includes membership choices at checkout; compare the complete multi-year cost. Its 58 × 21.5-inch footprint and 124-pound listed weight matter if you must carry it upstairs or share a small room.
Choose another if: You prefer a service-neutral tablet bike or cannot justify a class membership.
Search Amazon US for Echelon Connect EX-5s-22 (confirm exact model and generation).
Sunny Health & Fitness Active 100 SF-B124066: Basic connected magnetic bike
Best for: A rider seeking a basic magnetic bike with a small monitor and optional phone app.
Pros
- Stepless magnetic resistance and belt drive
- Built-in metrics plus optional SunnyFit Bluetooth pairing
- Compact listed 42.5 × 22.4-inch floor dimensions
Cons and trade-offs
- Handlebars have no adjustment listed
- Caged pedals only, not SPD clips
- 265-pound maker-listed user limit is lower than other picks
Our recommendation
Active 100 is the current low-complexity substitute for the older vague YOSUDA budget entry. It has a basic monitor for time, speed, distance and cadence plus Bluetooth connection to SunnyFit, so classes need not be embedded in an expensive screen. The crucial fit limitation is its fixed handlebar position; if your reach does not feel right, buy an adjustable model. The manufacturer lists a 265-pound capacity, 18-pound flywheel and 60.4-pound product weight. Check inseam fit against its published adjustment range before purchase.
Choose another if: You need fore-aft handlebar adjustment, SPD pedals or a heavier-duty user-weight rating.
Exercise bike buying guide
For a closer premium-class choice, see our Peloton Bike+ versus S22i comparison. Our treadmill guide helps if walking or running is more likely to stick than cycling.
Set your training routine before your budget
Studio classes, outdoor-route simulation and self-directed intervals are different habits. A built-in screen can make starting a session easy, but the subscription is a continuing part of the product. A tablet bike lets you change apps or ride from basic metrics. If you will not use classes several times a week, invest first in fit, stable construction and a resistance system you like.
Check fit and pedals
Compare your inseam with the maker’s adjustment range. Seat height and fore-aft placement, handlebar height and reach, and pedal stance affect comfort. Pedal systems differ: Peloton uses Delta-compatible cleats; Schwinn and Echelon offer SPD-compatible clips plus cages; Sunny Active 100 has cages only. Do not assume shoes transfer across systems. Stop and reassess if a position causes pain, and follow the machine’s setup instructions.
Measure the workout area
Published footprints do not include the rider, off-bike floor work or access for service. Check the door, stairs, ceiling, outlet and floor stability. Peloton’s body is listed at 54 × 22 inches; Echelon is 58 inches long; Schwinn IC4 is 30.7 inches wide. A mat may protect flooring, but it cannot fix an uneven surface or wobbling frame. Plan delivery and assembly for a machine over 100 pounds.
Understand resistance and incline
Magnetic resistance changes pedaling load with relatively little contact noise. Stepless controls offer feel-based adjustment; indexed levels help repeat a workout but are not comparable across brands. NordicTrack X24 physically changes incline and decline, a separate function from resistance. Its motor adds service considerations. No quoted calorie-burn multiplier should be treated as an individual result.
Price the whole relationship
Check the latest membership features, return terms, warranty exclusions, delivery and accessories at checkout. A class library can change; a bike should still have a usable manual mode. Ask what happens without membership and whether your preferred app shares cadence or resistance data as expected. The cheapest initial bike may not be cheapest over several years, while a premium screen is poor value if rarely used.
Frequently asked questions
Can I ride without a subscription?
Yes on several models, but available functions differ. Peloton offers Just Ride; Schwinn and Sunny have basic onboard metrics. Confirm current limits for each connected screen before purchase.
Are all resistance levels comparable?
No. A “level 20” on one bike is not a standardized load on another. Use the controls and your effort, not a cross-brand number, to judge fit.
Is S22i the current NordicTrack bike?
NordicTrack currently lists X24 for terrain training. S22i is a legacy model; see our separate Bike+ versus S22i comparison for used-purchase checks.
Do I need cycling shoes?
Peloton Bike+ requires Delta-compatible cleats. Schwinn IC4 and Echelon include cages and SPD-compatible clips; Sunny Active 100 lists caged pedals.
Does heavier flywheel mean a better bike?
Flywheel weight affects feel but does not alone establish smoother operation or build quality. Fit, resistance design, stability and service matter more.
How much space should I leave around an exercise bike?
Allow room to mount, dismount and turn the handlebars, plus any floor exercises you plan to do. Follow the maker’s clearance instructions and measure your doorways.
Research method and primary sources
We compared current US maker pages for fit, controls, screen, resistance, membership and dimensions. We have no original ride, sound or durability tests. Manufacturer performance statements are not treated as our measurements.
Primary sources: Peloton Cross Training Bike+ manufacturer page; Schwinn IC4 manufacturer page; NordicTrack X24 Bike manufacturer page; Echelon Connect EX-5s-22 manufacturer page; Sunny Health & Fitness Active 100 SF-B124066 manufacturer page; Peloton Just Ride support. Our methodology.
Affiliate disclosure
As an Amazon Associate, The Gear Audit earns from qualifying purchases. We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Full affiliate disclosure.